Run to Michael's right now and pick up this.
Sorry to be so bossy about it but you won't believe how cute you can make it. It's in the kid's craft section and it'll set you back only about $3 or so. Maybe it was $3.99...a bargain when you see how cute it gets.
Tune back in this evening and I'll show you what I mean. In the meantime, get thee to Michael's.